top of page


Maddy-headshot white background.jpg

Maddy Camay is a consistent top producer who has been selling real estate since 1991.  She dedicates time educating her buyers and sellers so that they feel comfortable every step of the way.  Maddy makes sure that they find the right match for their needs, hopes and dreams.  A strong negotiator, she works diligently to market, qualify and secure the best price. Integrity and passion infuse each transaction.


She services the Dix Hills & Melville areas in addition to Brookville, Jericho, Muttontown, Plainview, Oyster Bay Cove, Syosset and Woodbury.  Maddy's specializes in residential single family homes, condominiums, luxury and new construction.



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

02/23/2022 - Glen Stifelman

Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Plainview, NY.

Maddy did a great job selling our home and walking us through the process!

She set the price in such a way as we came out way ahead.

This was due to her knowledge of the market.


Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

10/04/2021 - zuser20170411134520749

We truly feel so lucky to have worked with Maddy in purchasing our new home.

From the beginning to the end of this process, Maddy showed genuine care, honesty,
and put our best interest at heart. We had no doubt that we were in good hands.
Maddy offered us professional and helpful advice, and without her skills,we likely
wouldn’t have landed on our dream home. Cannot recommend Maddy enough!


Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

08/17/2021 - esflatow
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Dix Hills, NY.

My wife and I couldn't have asked for a better experience than the one we had with Maddy.

She felt like family the second we met her, and she couldn't have been more helpful throughout
the entire buying process. She's knowledgeable, she has outstanding relationships, and

she's super trustworthy. We followed her guidance from start to finish, and it paid off.
We really can't thank her enough. She'll be the first non-family member we have over to

our new home - that's for sure!


Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

05/21/2021 - klik

Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Dix Hills, NY.


Maddy was terrific in every way. From pricing to showing to negotiating.

She always gave us good and fair advice. Was fantastic at showing our house
to eachand every buyer. Was efficient and quick to follow up after showings.

Recommend her very highly. She loves what she does and it shows.




Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

03/30/2021 - MelissaKatz3
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Dix Hills, NY.

Maddy is an amazing agent to work with if you are looking to buy a home!

She really helped us understand the entire process from start to finish.

She is extremely knowledgable and helped my husband and I find the
perfect home. We can't thank her enough!



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

07/12/2018 - zuser20180303124148041

Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Melville, NY.


Maddy Camay is a top notch agent who has true understanding of the Long Island real estate market.

She has successfully sold two homes for us and exceeded our expectations in terms of her strong

negotiation skills, strong communication with sellers and buyers and also works diligently to ensure

her clients experience smooth transactions from listing through closing. I think what separates Maddy

from other agents is her ability to truly listen to the needs of her clients. Maddy was always there for us

to answer any questions, or concerns. Her turnaround time was instant (even when she was on vacation)

She never made us feel alone throughout the process but instead partnered with us and was

always willing to lend an ear. It is without any hesitation that I recommend Maddy Camay.

You will not be disappointed with her service.




Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/09/2018 - user4757520

Maddy Camay is one the most dedicated and hard working agents out there. Her experience and knowledge of the area is unparalleled. Maddy listens to your wants and needs and will treat you like a member of her family. Her first priority was always making sure we were happy and that we were making the best choice. In addition, she will always be available to you and is extremely responsive. We have bought 2 houses and sold 1 with Maddy and each of our transactions have been wonderful.



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/08/2018 - JJJBMG1

You will not find a more dedicated, knowledable broker.

In addition to her expertise, she is amazing to work with!

She actually sold two of my houses in one day!!!



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/05/2018 - econdoleo
Bought a Single Family home in 2017 in Dix Hills, NY.

Maddy is the best real estate agent you could ever ask for.

She is very patient and determined to find what is right for

her clients. We were very fortunate to be able to work with her.



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/04/2018 - editon
Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Dix Hills, NY.


Maddy got the job done. We got a fair price for the house and sold it in a few months.

Marketed it within certain avenues that turned out to be fruitful. Maddy also discussed
the auction process as another avenue. While we did not go that route,it was eye-opening

to learn about that process. Happy with our experience.




Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/04/2018 - bbmax825
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2008 in Huntington, NY.

Madeleine Camay is a delight to work with. Finding a home is usually a stressful event.

Madeleine Camay makes it relaxing and fun. There is no pressure, just active listening and good advice.




Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

01/04/2018 - esturkey99

Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Melville, NY.


Maddy Camay has help me buy and sell 3 homes in the last 10 years.

Her knowledge of the market and negotiating skills has always been to my benefit.

I highly recommend her services if you want to get a deal done



Highly likely to recommend | 5.0

01/04/2018 - Erica Tymeck
Bought a Single Family home in 2017 in Dix Hills, NY.

Maddy understood our location, neighborhood and specific market in great detail.

Her knowledge and expertise where a huge asset. She negotiated a fair deal

and was always available to communicate and share information with us.



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

12/26/2016 - zuser20141203133925196

Bought and sold a Condo home in 2016 in Plainview, NY.


I have been working with Maddy for 10 years. She is the best out there.

She finds the perfect buyer and the perfect seller for all her clients. With Maddy it is a win win.

With her extensive experience and expertise in the field of selling real estate she will never

let you down and is a pleasure to work with. She is aggressive, honest and a master negotiator.

Maddy is smart, a very hard worker, loyal and a wonderful person.




Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

12/20/2016 - Melville1020
Sold a Single Family home in 2016 in Melville, NY.

Maddy is terrific. She's very easy to work with and works for YOU.

Maddy is extremely knowledgable, down to earth, reliable, responsible,

and pragmatic. She is always available and her response time to texts

and phone calls is lightening :) She's on it. She makes the process pleasant

and enjoyable. Maddy will represent your house with the highest level of

class and gusto! A pleasure to work with, highly recommended.



Highly likely to recommend  |  5.0

12/18/2016 - Jeff Berman

Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2013 in Melville, NY.

Most real estate brokers sell houses, Maddy is unique in that she sells homes.

By this I mean that Maddy gets to know her clients and what they need in not

only the brick and mortar of a house or condo but in neighbors, schools, lifestyles

and economics. Maddy's incredible in-depth knowledge of the Eastern Nassau and

Western Suffolk allowed her to guide us to make the right decision for our new home

and she was even able to time the sale of our existing home perfectly so that we were

able to do simultaneous closings. As we tried to sell our condo and buy a new home,

we were amazed by the fact that not only did Maddy know virtually every broker

but also many of the buyers and sellers we encountered were her clients as well.

We could not recommend Maddy any more highly and hope that she continues to

build on the incredible client base she so richly deserves.

more info on

bottom of page